John Smith Slim Sherman Actor Robert Fuller Jess Harper Actor Robert Crawford Jr. Andy Sherman Actor Stuart Randall Mort Corey Actor Charles Drake Matt Jessup Guest Star Phyllis Avery Mae Guest Star Leo Gordon Rafe Guest Star Judson Pratt Sheriff Guest Star Kevin Hagen Henchman Pete Guest Star Brad Weston Chuck Guest Star Harry Shannon Wilson Guest Star Jason Robards Sr. Dan Preston Guest Star Lesley Selander Director Jerry Adelman Writer