Tim Roth Dr. Cal Lightman Actor Kelli Williams Dr. Gillian Foster Actor Monica Raymund Ria Torres Actor Brendan Hines Eli Loker Actor Mekhi Phifer FBI Agent Ben Reynolds Actor Brian Howe Garrett Denning Guest Star Kari Coleman Mary, Mrs. McLaughlin Guest Star Arlene Tur Kimi Guest Star Matt Gerald Marshal Johnson Guest Star James Devoti Marshal Bernaski Guest Star Regi Davis Marshal Keller Guest Star Roy Werner Mark McLaughlin Guest Star Steve Mize Nick Guest Star Francisco Viana U.S. Marshal Guest Star Michael Harney Elliot Greene Guest Star Alicia Coppola Sheila Redatti Guest Star Hayley McFarland Emily Lightman Guest Star Samuel Baum Executive Producer Brian Grazer Executive Producer Rasheed Newson Writer T.J. Brady Writer Terrence O'Hara Director