Christina Ricci Lizzie Borden Actor, Executive Producer Clea Duvall Emma Borden Actor Cole Hauser Charlie Siringo Actor Dylan Taylor Officer Leslie Trotwood Actor Jonathan Banks Mr. Flowers Actor John Ralston Ezekiel Danforth Actor Bradley Stryker Skipjack Actor Jessy Schram Nancy O'Keefe Actor John Heard William Almy Actor Andrew Howard William Borden Actor Chris Bauer Tom Horn Guest Star Matthew Le Nevez Bat Masterson Guest Star Ronan Vibert Dr. Vose Guest Star Ryan Blakely Raymond Chaswick Guest Star Gage Munroe Everett Chaswick Guest Star Adrian G. Griffiths Frederick Lowell Guest Star Steven McCarthy Marshal Bagwell Guest Star Gianpaolo Venuta Jenkins Guest Star Paul Braunstein Stepfather Guest Star Matt Tolton Julius Lowell Guest Star Bill Carr Tomkins Guest Star Andrea Lee Norwood Daisy Guest Star Jennifer Morris Mrs. Pritchard Guest Star Carlyn Burchell Pearl Guest Star Isaac Mac Dougall Kid 1 Guest Star Raiden Moore Rusty Guest Star David Rossetti Attendant Timothy Guest Star Robert B. Kennedy Detective Morrisey Guest Star Keelin Jack Sherry Guest Star Judith Verno Executive Producer Gregory Small Writer Richard Blaney Writer Barbara Nance Writer Jason Grote Writer David Simkins Writer