Amy Poehler Host, Executive Producer Nick Offerman Host, Executive Producer Simon Doonan Judge Dayna Isom Johnson Judge Jimmy DiResta Actor Joanna Gick Contestant Amber Kemp-Gerstal Contestant Billy Kheel Contestant Robert Mahar Contestant Khiem Nguyen Contestant Jeffery Rudell Contestant Nicole Sweeney Contestant Brooke Posch Executive Producer Nicolle Yaron Executive Producer Dave Becky Executive Producer Anthony Dominici Executive Producer Andy Nelson Associate Director