François Arnaud Manfred Bernardo Actor Dylan Bruce Bobo Winthrop Actor Parisa Fitz-Henley Fiji Cavanaugh Actor Arielle Kebbel Olivia Charity Actor Sarah Ramos Creek Lovell Guest Star Peter Mensah Lemuel Bridger Actor Yul Vazquez Rev. Emilio Sheehan Actor Jason Lewis Joe Strong Actor Kellee Stewart Madonna Guest Star Jaime Ray Newman Patience Guest Star Nestor Carbonell Kai Guest Star Chelsea Edmundson Lyric Guest Star Claire Bryétt Andrew Sequoia Guest Star David Janollari Executive Producer Eric Charmelo Executive Producer Nicole Snyder Executive Producer Stacey K. Black Director Katie Lunskis Writer