Jason Lee Earl J. Hickey Actor Ethan Suplee Randy Hickey Actor Jaime Pressly Joy Darville Turner Actor Nadine Velazquez Catalina Aruca Actor Eddie Steeples Darnell Turner Actor Erik Estrada Erik Estrada Guest Star Louis T. Moyle Dodge Guest Star Trey Carlisle Earl Jr. Guest Star Brian Dunkleman Himself Guest Star Sandy Martin Joy's Grandma Guest Star Abdul Goznobi Iqball Guest Star Gigi Goff Young Joy Guest Star Gregor Manns Stage Manager Guest Star Kelli Goss Teenage Joy Guest Star Greg Garcia Executive Producer Marc Buckland Executive Producer Eyal Gordin Director Ralph Greene Writer