Michael Chiklis Jim Powell Actor Julie Benz Stephanie Powell Actor Romany Malco George St. Cloud Actor Autumn Reeser Katie Andrews Actor Kay Panabaker Daphne Powell Actor Jimmy Bennett JJ Powell Actor Stephen Collins Dr. Dayton King Actor Guillermo Díaz Guest Star Bruce McGill Guest Star Cybill Shepherd Guest Star Jackson Rathbone Guest Star Delaina Mitchell Guest Star John Burke Guest Star Matt Lasky Guest Star Jason Grey Guest Star Sean Douglas Guest Star Charles Carpenter Guest Star Jon Harmon Feldman Executive Producer Greg Berlanti Executive Producer Morgan Wandell Executive Producer David Semel Executive Producer Zack Estrin Writer Allison Adler Writer David Paymer Director