Colin Jost Host Barbara Gao Shapiro Contestant Erin McLean Contestant Jessica Babbit Contestant Mackenzie Jones Contestant Sam Spaulding Contestant Elise Nussbaum Contestant Hans Von Walter Contestant Michael Davies Executive Producer, Writer Buzzy Cohen Writer Lucinda Ireland Director Louis Virtel Writer Bari Jean Dorman Producer Billy Wisse Writer Michele Loud Writer Marcus Brown Writer Chip Dornell Writer John Duarte Writer Mark Gaberman Writer Debbie Griffin Writer Amy Ozols Writer