Alyssa Milano Host Isaac Mizrahi Judge Georgina Chapman Judge Anne Fulenwider Actor Kimberly Goldson Contestant Stanley Hudson Contestant Amanda Valentine Contestant Char Glover Contestant Kelly Dempsey Contestant Edmond Newton Contestant Candice Cuoco Contestant Merline Labissiere Contestant Anthony Williams Contestant Joshua McKinley Contestant Casanova Contestant Andy South Contestant Melissa Fleis Contestant Fabio Costa Contestant Helen Castillo Contestant Ken Laurence Contestant Danielle Brooks Guest