Bret Harrison Sam Oliver Actor Ray Wise The Devil Actor Tyler Labine Bert "Sock" Wysocki Actor Rick Gonzalez Ben Gonzalez Actor Missy Peregrym Andi Prendergast Actor Valarie Rae Miller Josie Actor Donavon Stinson Ted Actor Andrew Airlie Mr. Oliver Actor Michael Ian Black Guest Star Jessica Stroup Guest Star Ken Marino Guest Star Matthew Burgess Guest Star Allison Hossack Guest Star Tara Butters Executive Producer Michele Fazekas Executive Producer Michael Robison Director Treena Hancock Writer Melissa R. Byer Writer