Carla Triplett Contestant Joelle Gwynn Contestant Daniel Wright Contestant David Lee Contestant Sione Fa Contestant Filipe Fa Contestant Blaine Cotter Contestant Dane Patterson Contestant Damien Gurganious Contestant Nicole Brewer Contestant Tara Costa Contestant Laura Denoux Contestant Ron Morelli Contestant Mike Morelli Contestant Estella Hayes Contestant Gerald "Jerry" Hayes Contestant Helen Phillips Contestant Shanon Thomas Contestant Cathy Skell Contestant Kristin Steede Contestant Amanda Kramer Contestant Aubrey Cheney Contestant Tim Gunn Guest Star Alison Sweeney Host Ben Silverman Executive Producer David Broome Executive Producer J.D. Roth Executive Producer John Foy Executive Producer Todd Nelson Executive Producer