Alison Sweeney Host Jesse Atkins Contestant Montina Cooper Contestant Richard Deroque Contestant Alfredo Dinten Contestant Sandy Dolan Contestant Brendan Donovan Contestant Tina Elliott Contestant Sophia Franklin Contestant Patrick House Contestant Adam Hurtado Contestant Allie Ishcomer Contestant Burgandy Keel Contestant Shanna Masten Contestant Lisa Mosley Contestant Mark Pinhasovich Contestant Corey Pinkerton Contestant Elizabeth Ruiz Contestant Ada Wong Contestant Anna Wright Contestant Ben Silverman Executive Producer David Broome Executive Producer J.D. Roth Executive Producer John Foy Executive Producer Todd Nelson Executive Producer