Bob Harper Host Whitney Clay Contestant Felicia Buffkin Contestant Vicki Clark Contestant Lauren Clark Contestant Rob Kidney Contestant Sarah Gilbert Contestant Tonsheia "Toy" Grandison Contestant Britney Anderson Contestant Luis Hernandez Contestant Roberto Hernandez Contestant Jacky Kmet Contestant Stephen Kmet Contestant Hope Wright Contestant Colby Wright Contestant Richard Hatch Contestant Erin Willett Contestant Lorena García Guest Tim Gunn Guest Ken Paves Guest Ben Silverman Executive Producer David Broome Executive Producer Todd Lubin Executive Producer Lisa Hennessy Executive Producer Eden Gaha Executive Producer J.D. Roth Executive Producer Todd Nelson Executive Producer