Kevin James Doug Heffernan Actor, Executive Producer Leah Remini Carrie Heffernan Actor Jerry Stiller Arthur Spooner Actor Victor Williams Deacon Palmer Actor Patton Oswalt Spence Olchin Actor Gary Valentine Danny Heffernan Actor Nicole Sullivan Actor Neil Sedaka Guest Star James Lancaster Guest Star Danny Goldman Guest Star Alex Rayfiel Guest Star David Haydn-Jones Guest Star Michael J. Weithorn Executive Producer Josh Goldsmith Executive Producer Cathy Yuspa Executive Producer David Bickel Writer Rob Schiller Director Nick Bakay Writer