Bret Harrison Sam Sullivan Actor Eric Christian Olsen Sully Sullivan Actor Amanda Loncar Piper Actor Sarah Wright Lizzy Actor Philip Baker Hall Russ McDonald Actor Mimi Rogers Meryl St. James Actor Joy Osmanski Darcy Actor Rachel Boston Guest Star S. Marc Jordan Guest Star Matt Corboy Guest Star Lance E. Nichols Guest Star Joseph Limbaugh Guest Star Crystal Kwon Guest Star Denver Dowridge Guest Star Will Gluck Executive Producer Pam Brady Executive Producer