Martha Plimpton Eileen Actor Jay R. Ferguson Pat Actor Noah Galvin Kenny Actor Matt Shively Jimmy Actor Bebe Wood Shannon Actor Mary Hollis Inboden Jodi Actor Brian Huskey Father Phil Guest Star Jeremy Lawson Jesus Guest Star Hannah Marks Mimi Guest Star Sarayu Blue Marcia Worthman Guest Star Max Emerson Cologne Man Guest Star Efrain Figueroa Bishop Perez Guest Star Jinhee Joung Waitress Guest Star Gloria Calderon Kellett Woman Guest Star Scott Menville Gangbanger Guest Star Keri Safran Crystal Guest Star Scot Zeller Middle Aged Dentist Guest Star David Windsor Executive Producer, Writer Casey Johnson Executive Producer, Writer Brian Pines Executive Producer Dan McDermott Executive Producer Stacy Traub Executive Producer Dan Savage Executive Producer Joshua Sternin Writer Jennifer Ventimilia Writer