Jamie Bell Abraham Woodhull Actor Seth Numrich Ben Tallmadge Actor Daniel Henshall Caleb Brewster Actor Heather Lind Anna Strong Actor Meegan Warner Mary Woodhull Actor Kevin R. McNally Judge Richard Woodhull Actor Burn Gorman Maj. Edmund Hewlett Actor Angus Macfadyen Robert Rogers Actor Samuel Roukin Lt. John Simcoe Actor JJ Feild Maj. John Andre Actor Michael Gaston Gen. Scott Guest Star Jamie Harris Will Robeson Guest Star Amy Gumenick Philomena Guest Star Adam Brock Ensign Clayton Guest Star Ashley Smith Lt. Wakefield Guest Star Thomas Keegan Ensign Baker Guest Star Joseph Carlson Quill Guest Star Johnny Day Redcoat Guest Star L. Derek Leonidoff Capt. Joyce Guest Star Ryan Adcock Lord Monteagle Guest Star Billy Obryen Cobb Mercenary, Redcoat Guest Star Chris Condetti Townsperson Guest Star Parker Coughlin Redcoat, Green Bonnet Guest Star James Davenjay Militia Soldier Guest Star Noah Downs Redcoat, Hessian Guest Star Rachel Faulkner Townsperson Guest Star Thomas Fisher Townsperson Guest Star Brandon Hoover Redcoat Guest Star Tim Krems Stage Manager Guest Star Garrett Leighton Town Kid Guest Star Rachel Rose Lynch Masked Festival Girl Guest Star Jody Matzer Setauket Townsperson Guest Star John McAdorey British Soldier Guest Star Aaron T. Mott Redcoat Sentry Guest Star James Nevins Setauket Townsperson Guest Star Alexander Pennecke Redcoat Guest Star Whit Sheppard Devil Stagehand Guest Star Matthew Sims Upper Class New Yorker Guest Star Mike Stevens Redcoat Guest Star Luke Van Bergen Redcoat Guest Star Idara Victor Abigail Guest Star Barry Josephson Executive Producer Craig Silverstein Executive Producer, Writer Ed Bianchi Director