Poppy Montgomery Carrie Wells Actor Dylan Walsh Det. Al Burns Actor Michael Gaston Det. Mike Costello Actor Kevin Rankin Det. Roe Saunders Actor Daya Vaidya Det. Nina Inara Actor Britt Lower Tanya Sitkowsky Guest Star Jane Curtin Joanne Webster Guest Star James Urbaniak Richard Simmons Guest Star Chris Beetem Duane Tate Guest Star Anne Bates Allyson Tate Guest Star Harriet D. Foy Nurse Guest Star Michael De Nola Cook Guest Star Ramona Keller Woman Guest Star Jeremy Brena Ted Rosio Guest Star Roger Brenner FDNY , EMT Guest Star Carol Commissiong NYPD Officer Guest Star Carl Ducena NYPD Officer Guest Star Gregg Micheals Boatman Guest Star Ed Redlich Executive Producer, Writer John Bellucci Executive Producer, Writer Sarah Timberman Executive Producer Carl Beverly Executive Producer Aaron Lipstadt Director