Shiri Appleby Rachel Goldberg Actor Constance Zimmer Quinn King Actor Craig Bierko Chet Actor Freddie Stroma Adam Cromwell Actor Josh Kelly Jeremy Actor Siobhan Williams Lizzie Actor Nathalie Kelley Grace Actor Johanna Braddy Anna Actor Breeda Wool Faith Actor Ashley Scott Mary Actor Jeffrey Bowyer-Chapman Jay Actor Aline Elasmar Shia Actor Arielle Kebbel Britney Actor Brennan Elliott Graham Actor Amy Hill Dr. Wagerstein Actor Stephanie Bennett Pepper Actor Andrea Brooks Tanya Actor Genevieve Buechner Madison Actor Natasha Burnett Athena Actor Melissa Marie Elias Crystal Actor Elise Gatien Rita Actor Christie Laing Shamiqua Actor Natasha Wilson Maya Actor Emily Maddison Claire Actor Aidan Dee Crew Chick Guest Star Tommy Douglas Suitor Guest Star Everick Golding Officer Guest Star Graeme McComb AD Sam Guest Star Donavon Stinson AD Dan Guest Star Robert M. Sertner Executive Producer Sally DeSipio Executive Producer