Shiri Appleby Rachel Goldberg Actor Constance Zimmer Quinn King Actor Craig Bierko Chet Actor Josh Kelly Jeremy Actor Jeffrey Bowyer-Chapman Jay Actor B.J. Britt Darius Hill Actor Monica Barbaro Yael Actor Denée Benton Ruby Carter Actor Kim Matula Tiffany James Actor Michael Rady Coleman Wasserman Actor Meagan Tandy Chantal Actor Gentry White Romeo Guest Star Genevieve Buechner Madison Guest Star Brennan Elliott Graham Guest Star Carl Lumbly Dr. Henry Carter Guest Star Lindsay Musil Beth Ann Guest Star Karissa Tynes Jameson Guest Star Elizabeth Whitmere Dominique Guest Star Ioan Gruffudd John Booth Guest Star Jennifer Breslow Director