Tony Bill Director, Producer Christian Slater Adam Actor Marisa Tomei Caroline Actor Rosie Perez Cindy Actor Kyle Secor Howard Actor Willie Garson Patsy Actor James Cada Bill No. 1 Actor Gary Groomes Bill No. 2 Actor Claudia Wilkens Mother Camilla Actor Pat Clemons Sister Helen Actor Lotis Key Nun Actor Vanessa Hart Nun Actor Charley Bartlett Young Adam Actor Vincent Kartheiser Orphan Boy Actor Wendy Feder Orphange Nurse Actor Nancy Marvy Caroline's Mom Actor Paul Douglas Law Steven Actor Joshua Schaefer Michael Actor Marquetta Senters Mary Actor Joe Minjares Jim Actor Joe Schmit Sportscaster Actor John Beasley Cook Actor Steve Cochran Stromboli Actor Sally Wingert Tree Customer Actor Richard Grusin Caroline's Father Actor Buffy Sedlachek Lottie Actor Tom Sierchio Ronnie Actor, Screenwriter Aaron Kjenaas Nick Actor Isabell O'Connor Police Officer Actor Allen Hamilton Doctor Actor Kay Bonner Nee Beauty Shop Customer Actor Helen Buck Bartlett Producer J. Boyce Harman Jr. Executive Producer Jost Vacano Cinematographer Mia Goldman Film Editing Cliff Eidelman Original Music Steven Jordan Production Design Jack Ballance Art Director Cliff Cunningham Set Decoration Lynette Bernay Costume Design Marci Liroff Casting