Nick Kroll Nick Creator, Voice, Executive Producer Andrew Goldberg Creator, Executive Producer Mark Levin Creator, Executive Producer Jennifer Flackett Creator, Executive Producer John Mulaney Andrew Voice Maya Rudolph Diane Voice Jason Mantzoukas Jay Voice Jordan Peele Ghost of Duke Ellington Voice Fred Armisen Elliot Voice Jenny Slate Missy Voice Jessi Klein Jessi Voice Gina Rodriguez Gina Voice David Thewlis The Shame Wizard Voice Jonathan Van Ness Himself Guest Voice Karamo Brown Himself Guest Voice Bobby Berk Himself Guest Voice Tan France Himself Guest Voice Antoni Porowski Himself Guest Voice