Andie MacDowell Judge Olivia Lockhart Actor Dylan Neal Jack Griffith Actor Brennan Elliott Warren Saget Actor Teryl Rothery Grace Sherman Actor Sarah Smyth Justine Actor Timothy Webber Moon Actor Sebastian Spence Cliff Harting Actor Jesse Hutch Luke Bailey Actor Cameron Bancroft Will Jeffers Actor Elyse Levesque Maryellen Sherman Actor Tom Butler Buck Saget Actor Colin Ferguson Paul Watson Actor Cindy Busby Rebecca Jennings Actor Rebecca Marshall Alex Baldwin Actor Sarah-Jane Redmond Corrie Mcafee Guest Star Mike Dopud Roy Mcafee Guest Star Anna Van Hooft Linnette Mcafee Guest Star Bruce Dawson David Guest Star Clare Filipow Lisa Guest Star Sebastian Stewart Tom Guest Star Dan Wigutow Executive Producer Ron French Executive Producer Sue Tenney Executive Producer, Writer Andy Mikita Director Amy Palmer Robertson Writer