Rachel Bloom Rebecca Bunch Actor, Executive Producer Vincent Rodriguez III Josh Chan Actor Donna Lynne Champlin Paula Proctor Actor Pete Gardner Darryl Whitefeather Actor Vella Lovell Heather Davis Actor Gabrielle Ruiz Valencia Actor Scott Michael Foster Nathaniel Plimpton III Actor David Hull White Josh Actor Aline Brosh McKenna Executive Producer Marc Webb Executive Producer Erin Ehrlich Executive Producer Michael Hitchcock Writer Stuart McDonald Director