Jemaine Clement Jemaine Actor, Writer Bret McKenzie Bret Actor, Writer Rhys Darby Murray Hewitt Actor Kristen Schaal Mel Actor Arj Barker Dave Actor James Callanan Bruce Guest Star Victoria Cesarski Keitha's Housemate Guest Star Alan Gary Dancing Bartender Guest Star Randy Jones Bouncer Guest Star Dena Kaplan Keli Guest Star Tiffany Limos Herself Guest Star José Ramón Rosario Hansom Cab Driver Guest Star Sarah Wynter Keitha Guest Star Elli N.Z. Pedestrian Guest Star James Bobin Writer Troy Miller Executive Producer Stu Smiley Executive Producer Tracey Baird Executive Producer Michel Gondry Director