Jay R. Ferguson Chip Actor Lindsey Kraft Leslie Actor Ian Gomez Father Gene Actor David Krumholtz Rabbi Gil Actor Tony Rock Vince Actor Camryn Manheim Ms. Meadows Actor Sara Gilbert Cheryl Guest Star Gary Kraus Rick Guest Star AJ Rivera Florist Guest Star Forte Rodriguez Police Officer Guest Star Lateefah Holder Ticket Clerk Guest Star Patrick Walsh Executive Producer Johnny Galecki Executive Producer Andrew Haas Executive Producer Spencer Medof Executive Producer Andy Ackerman Executive Producer, Director Sophia Lear Writer