Karlie Kloss Host, Executive Producer Christian Siriano Actor Nina Garcia Judge Brandon Maxwell Judge Elaine Welteroth Judge Afa Ah Loo Contestant Rakan Shams Aldeen Contestant Cavanagh Baker Contestant Tessa Clark Contestant Bishme Cromartie Contestant Venny Etienne Contestant Jhoan "Sebastian" Grey Contestant Renee Hill Contestant Sonia Kasparian Contestant Kovid Kapoor Contestant Frankie Lewis Contestant Lela Orr Contestant Jamall Osterholm Contestant Nadine Ralliford Contestant Gary "Garo Sparo" Spampinato Contestant Hester Sunshine Contestant Dan Cutforth Executive Producer Jane Lipsitz Executive Producer Casey Kriley Executive Producer Nan Strait Executive Producer Gayle Gawlowski Executive Producer Andy Mitchell Executive Producer Milos Brajovic Executive Producer Shea Spencer Co-Executive Producer Meri Haitkin Co-Executive Producer