Alison Sweeney Host Lindsay Bravo Contestant Sanjana "Sunny" Chandrasekar Contestant Noah "Biingo" Gray Contestant Danni Allen Contestant Jackson Carter Contestant Nicole "Nikki" Davis Contestant Michael Dorsey Contestant Pamela Geil Contestant David Jones Contestant Cate Laughlin Contestant Gina McDonald Contestant Nate Montgomery Contestant Francelina Morillo Contestant Jeff Nichols Contestant Joe Ostaszewski Contestant Thomas "T.C." Pool Contestant Lisa Rambo Contestant Alexandra "Alex" Reid Contestant Ken Paves Guest Star Ben Silverman Executive Producer David Broome Executive Producer Todd Lubin Executive Producer Lisa Hennessy Executive Producer Eden Gaha Executive Producer J.D. Roth Executive Producer Paul Franklin Executive Producer Todd Nelson Executive Producer