Alfonso Herrera Father Tomas Ortega Actor Ben Daniels Father Marcus Keane Actor Kurt Egyiawan Father Bennett Actor Hannah Kasulka Casey Rance Actor Geena Davis Angela Rance Actor Alan Ruck Henry Rance Actor Brianne Howey Katherine Rance Actor Camille Guaty Olivia Guest Star Francis Guinan Brother Simon Guest Star Alan Metoskie Homeless Man Guest Star Matthew Velasquez Luis Guest Star Ana María Alvarez Helena Guest Star Ann Whitney Mrs. Finley Guest Star Melissa Russell Tara Guest Star Christopher Meister Construction Worker Guest Star Jeremy Slater Executive Producer Rolin Jones Executive Producer James G. Robinson Executive Producer Barbara Wall Executive Producer David Robinson Executive Producer Rupert Wyatt Executive Producer Roy Lee Executive Producer