Aug 12, 2014
Connected with Demy's debut <i>Lola</i> (1961), not only because taking place in the famous place of Cherbourg that was mentioned a lot, but also because of character references, such as Lola's infancy friend Roland Cassard and Lola herself, <i>The Umbrellas of Cherbourg</i> represents the epitome of Demy's musical delightfulness. We saw it coming since <i>Lola</i>, perhaps subconsciously, but now his musicals do have singing and complement the situations marvelously.
I had personally never imagined to see a director officially considered as a part of the Nouvelle Vague movement adapting the Hollywood tradition to the big screens of France with renowned actresses such as Anouk Aimée, Jeanne Moreau and Catherine Deneuve. And what was the Academy Awards reaction to this? Oh, the most predictable in the world, of course:
- An Oscar nomination for Best Writing, Story and Screenplay - Written Directly for the Screen (Jacques Demy)
- An Oscar nomination for Best Music, Original Song (<i>"I Will Wait for You"</i>)
- An Oscar nomination for Best Music, Score - Substantially Original
- An Oscar nomination for Best Music, Scoring of Music, Adaptation or Treatment
- An Oscar nomination for Best Foreign Language Film
Because the Academy will nominate always in terms of thematic conservatism and visual attractiveness. Musicals are also their weakest bias spot...
Anyway, <i>The Umbrellas of Cherbourg</i> stands out in a number of ways, but I'll mention the two which I consider the most important.
Firstly, it breaks the common Hollywood structure of musicals. The whole story is <b>ENTIRELY</b> sung. Whereas in Hollywood you would see the story develop for then arriving to key moments in which characters would start singing out of the blue to explain scenarios, create uplifting moments or simply complement a situation, here not a single word is spoken if it is not sung. Few will realize the exhausting amount of effort that requires, including screenwriting, effort by the cast, and time calculations of entry and exit, but fortunately the majority will be delighted throughout.
Secondly, it is a thought-provoking drama. Musicals portraying a story about hardships, struggles or other serious issues were very rare (which is one of the reasons why <i>West Side Story</i> [1961] is unique). The constant singing could be considered a distractor, or a negatively impactful source of cognitive dissonance, but it is not. Au contraire, despite the sad or tragic moments, the film is elevated to a charming level where you feel you are floating throughout, from beginning to end, and as it is a tradition in Demy's dramatic vision, the story is not ended like Hollywood would.
Finally, despite this dangerous stunt, Demy is perfectly capable of emanating the feelings intended in the required moments: heartwarming drama, clichés*,
humor, shock, and even tears during the departure scene or the very ending. The whole cast shines thanks to their impeccable effort, and thanks to a glorious use of Eastmancolor, which would definitely look great in Blu-Ray, the whole scenarios interact with the film's magic. Ironically, we were talked about Cherbourg in <i>Lola</i> about a boring place from which people would seek to escape whenever they could, but it is a place full of music, colors, emotions and snow.
Haters of the musical genre because of its fantastical unrealism and because people are taking off the story by characters suddenly singing should <b>mandatorily</b> check this reinvention of the genre as a last opportunity, because even the musical genre has boundaries unexplored thanks to the Hollywood/Bollywood cinematic duopoly. It is, indeed, a rarity of an opera.
94/100
Verified