New York Tribune

Tomatometer-approved publication
Rating Title/Year Author
Back to God's Country (1919) Harriette Underhill The picture gives Miss Shipman emotional opportunities and her work is impressive. EDIT
Posted Nov 12, 2019
Stella Maris (1918) Harriette Underhill If any there be who think that Mary Pickford is not. a great actress let him go to see Stella Maris and be convinced. EDIT
Posted Nov 11, 2019
() Ishbel M. Ross [On With the Dance] is a feast for the eye, even if it does not put much of a strain on the intelligence. EDIT
Posted Nov 8, 2019
() Edwin H. Blanchard A moving story, rich in beautiful scenes and well acted. EDIT
Posted Nov 8, 2019
Huckleberry Finn (1920) Edwin H. Blanchard It is true to the spirit of the book almost entirely, and departs from the letter only when forced to by physical reasons. EDIT
Posted Nov 8, 2019
() Edwin H. Blanchard The picture fails to interest deeply because the real thing is so short a distance in the past that we are not ready yet for substitutes; and also because of organic defects in the picture itself. EDIT
Posted Nov 8, 2019
() Edwin H. Blanchard The outdoor scenes in this picture are of great beauty. and the work of Miss Sweet is, of course, very acceptable and more. EDIT
Posted Nov 8, 2019
() Ishbel M. Ross The acting of Lionel Barrymore has made it a great picture. EDIT
Posted Nov 8, 2019
() Ishbel M. Ross The action is so swift it makes one dizzy. And no one has a chance to be bored. EDIT
Posted Nov 8, 2019
Beyond the Rocks (1922) Harriette Underhill No one seemed to take the picture very seriously excepting the hero and heroine, and we are not sure that they did. EDIT
Posted Nov 8, 2019
Sherlock Holmes (1922) Harriette Underhill Sherlock Holmes is interesting as a picture chiefly because of the cast and the exteriors. EDIT
Posted Nov 8, 2019
Loves of Pharaoh (1922) Harriette Underhill It is a picture that appeals solely to the eye and never to the heart. EDIT
Posted Nov 8, 2019
Orphans of the Storm (1922) Harriette Underhill As yet we cannot write nor think calmly of it. Beautiful picture follows beautiful picture, thrill follows thrill so fast. EDIT
Posted Nov 8, 2019
Foolish Wives (1922) Harriette Underhill The picture seems to us to be without a flaw. EDIT
Posted Nov 8, 2019
() Harriette Underhill The screen should amuse, entertain or thrill and also please the eye. A Doll's House does none of these things. EDIT
Posted Nov 8, 2019
() Harriette Underhill The titles are a delight, the picture is beautifully directed and the cast leaves nothing to be desired. EDIT
Posted Nov 7, 2019
() Harriette Underhill It is an intricate though fascinating story of political intrigue as well as domestic complications, and James Kirkwood as the English lord and the German spy, himself gives a great impersonation. EDIT
Posted Nov 7, 2019
() Harriette Underhill As we left the theatre we wanted to cry "George Loane Tucker is great! Hugo Reisenfeld is great! 'The Miracle Man' is great!" EDIT
Posted Nov 7, 2019
() Harriette Underhill If it had not boon tor the delightful personality and the art of Miss Talmadge we think The Wonderful Thing would have been a very dull thing. EDIT
Posted Nov 7, 2019
() Harriette Underhill [It's] a most ingenious attempt to crowd into six reels every form of human baseness, and jealousy, anger, cowardice, gossiping, treachery, robbery, money lust, sex |lust, murder or hypocrisy might with equal justice have been assigned the title role. EDIT
Posted Nov 7, 2019
() Harriette Underhill A distinct disappointment. EDIT
Posted Nov 7, 2019
() Harriette Underhill Henry Kolker has done a great piece of work in the direction and the star, Mr. Arliss, possesses more magnetism than most of the handsome heroes of the screen combined. EDIT
Posted Nov 7, 2019
() Harriette Underhill Miss Weber has put the picture on with her usual veracity. She never has any "big moments" in her pictures, and her people act just as they do in real life. EDIT
Posted Nov 7, 2019
Tol'able David (1921) Harriette Underhill We left the theater last night vowing it was the best picture of the year (not the new year either). EDIT
Posted Nov 7, 2019
The Sheik (1921) Harriette Underhill The Sheik is the sort of story which will make every woman who is married to a kind and indulgent husband go home from the theater and feel her heart riled with a great pity for him because he is so prosy, and a greater pity for herself. EDIT
Posted Nov 6, 2019
() Harriette Underhill This new picture which Ernest Lubitsch has sent us has everything in it which makes the German films such joyous things. EDIT
Posted Nov 6, 2019
The Idle Class (1921) Harriette Underhill The Idle Class is quite different from anything Chaplin has done, and we like it better than anything, excepting Shoulder Arms and The Kid. EDIT
Posted Nov 6, 2019
The Three Musketeers (1921) Harriette Underhill The Three Musketeers is a thrilling, gripping, unadulterated success. EDIT
Posted Nov 6, 2019
At the End of the World (1921) Harriette Underhill Betty Compton endowed it with a very handsome heroine in Cherry and a wardrobe which is in itself a snare. EDIT
Posted Nov 6, 2019
The Conquering Power (1921) Harriette Underhill We sat spellbound while the story was unfolded on the screen, charmed by the youthful appeal, vivacity and cleverness of Rudolph Valentino. EDIT
Posted Nov 6, 2019
Through the Back Door (1921) Harriette Underhill It is so silly and so cheap that we found it difficult to place the blame where it belonged and not pas'i on our resentment to Mary Pickford, the star. We are. quite sure, however, that when Mary did it she must have sighed resignedly. EDIT
Posted Nov 6, 2019
Now or Never (1921) Harriette Underhill Lloyd is one of the finest comedians on the screen. EDIT
Posted Nov 6, 2019
Gypsy Blood (1921) Harriette Underhill Never have we seen such realism on the screen and Pola Negri is a powerful actress, who is fascinating, beautiful in a way that has character for its foundation, and intelligent. EDIT
Posted Nov 6, 2019
Peck's Bad Boy (1921) Harriette Underhill We cannot enjoy characters in a play unless they have a counterpart in real life and surely no five-year-old boy ever was like this one. EDIT
Posted Nov 6, 2019
The Sky Pilot (1921) Harriette Underhill The photography is beautiful and there is one scene where the hero prevents the heroine from being trampled to death by thousands of wild steers which is perfectly thrilling. EDIT
Posted Nov 6, 2019
The Saphead (1921) Harriette Underhill Saphead is much too mild an epithet. William H. Crane is co-starred with Buster Keaton, but both will undoubtedly be able to live it down. EDIT
Posted Nov 6, 2019
The Kid (1921) Harriette Underhill The Kid is a vastly entertaining picture, but there are some things in it which, we believe, were better left unsaid. Why is it that Chaplin, who is really an idealist, always has touches of vulgarity in his pictures? EDIT
Posted Nov 6, 2019
Outside the Law (1920) Harriette Underhill Those who like crook melodrama with scenes in Chinatown ave certainly going to like Outside the Law, for it is much bigger than anything of the kind we have seen. EDIT
Posted Nov 6, 2019
The Love Light (1921) Harriette Underhill The Love Light is a fascinating story beautifully produced and marvelously well acted. EDIT
Posted Nov 6, 2019
The Last of the Mohicans (1920) Harriette Underhill If we had read the book, perhaps we should not have enjoyed the picture much as we did, for it is a perfectly thrilling picture. EDIT
Posted Nov 6, 2019
() Edwin H. Blanchard It is an ancient theme, perhaps, but the manner in which Douglas MacLean as the ingenious doctor, and Doris May as Mary Jane Smith, tell it adorns it with new youth. EDIT
Posted Oct 24, 2019
() Edwin H. Blanchard It is a well-told story and the acting is good. EDIT
Posted Oct 18, 2019
My Wife's Relations (1922) Harriette Underhill Slapstick comedies are not the least bit amusing to us. We used to hope that we should reform, but now we're sure we never shall. EDIT
Posted Sep 12, 2019
() Harriette Underhill The picture is just another one of those things which people who never think anything because they have nothing to think about and nothing to think with are going to like. It ought to make a lot of money. EDIT
Posted Sep 12, 2019
() Harriette Underhill It never seems to have the courage of its convictions, but jumps all over the place and when it is finished you feel as though you bad been looking at an old fashioned crazy quilt. EDIT
Posted Sep 12, 2019
() Harriette Underhill The picture did not impress us in the least. EDIT
Posted Sep 12, 2019
To Have and to Hold (2001) Harriette Underhill George Fitzmaurice has done fine things with the direction and he also has selected a splendid cast. EDIT
Posted Sep 12, 2019
One Exciting Night (1922) Harriette Underhill One Exciting Night is exciting, but just what else it is is difficult to say. EDIT
Posted Sep 12, 2019
() Harriette Underhill The picture which leads up to this flood is quite unworthy of such a stupendous climax; in fact, it is nil, but whatever you may think of it you will feel amply repaid when the deluge comes along. EDIT
Posted Sep 12, 2019
() Harriette Underhill In spite of this lack of novelty the picture started off well enough because the director put in a lot of little incidents which were human and amusing. But it soon ran away from him completely. EDIT
Posted Sep 12, 2019